Commit graph

81 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Kristiyan Kostadinov
c07805612f test(core): clean up unnecessary nesting in old tests (#52239)
A lot of our tests are wrapped in `{}` which serves no purpose, aside from increasing the nesting level and, in some cases, causing confusion. The braces appear to be a leftover from a time when all tests were wrapped in a `function main() {}`. The function declaration was removed in #21053, but the braces remained, presumably because it was easier to search&replace for `function main()`, but not to remove the braces at the same time.

PR Close #52239
2023-10-19 09:26:15 -07:00
Alan Agius
1640743b18 Revert "perf(platform-browser): disable styles of removed components instead of removing (#51808)" (#52238)
This reverts commit 65786b2b96 due to an oberved perf regression in Pantheon.

See: http://b/303667704

PR Close #52238
2023-10-18 11:34:21 +02:00
Matt Lewis
65786b2b96 fix(platform-browser): prevent duplicate stylesheets from being created (#52019)
Fixes a bug with REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY when a component is destroyed and re-created, its previous stylesheets will not be re-used and instead a new stylesheet will still be created each time.

PR Close #52019
2023-10-05 14:06:56 -07:00
Alan Agius
3c0577f991 perf(platform-browser): disable styles of removed components instead of removing (#51808)
This commit changes the behaviour of `REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY`.

Now, `style` nodes are disabled instead of removed from DOM. This causes the same runtime behaviour but avoids recomputations when the stylesheet is re-added when the component is re-created. https://source.chromium.org/chromium/chromium/src/+/main:third_party/blink/renderer/core/css/css_style_sheet.h;l=266;drc=31fb07c05718d671d96c227855bfe97af9e3fb20

NB: This changes is being done following some performance bottlenecks observed in Phanteon and their own recommendations.

Context:
http://chat/room/AAAAxKxTk40/jaP6Lj6fhmQ/jaP6Lj6fhmQ
https://crbug.com/1444522
http://b/289992821

PR Close #51808
2023-09-22 09:48:35 -07:00
Alan Agius
c340d6e044 feat(platform-browser): enable removal of styles on component destroy by default (#51571)
This change aligns the settings between G3 and P3 as `REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY_DEFAULT` is already set to `true` internally.

BREAKING CHANGE: `REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY` default value is now `true`. This causes CSS of components to be removed from the DOM when destroyed. You retain the previous behaviour by providing the `REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY` injection token.

```ts
import {REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY} from '@angular/platform-browser';
...
providers: [{
  provide: REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY,
  useValue: false,
}]
```

PR Close #51571
2023-08-30 14:42:02 +00:00
Alan Agius
0380564f85 fix(platform-browser): wait until animation completion before destroying renderer (#50860)
Prior to this commit, the renderer destroy method was being called before the animation complete. This is problematic when using `REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY` as it causes the styles to be removed too early.

This commit, updates this destroy logic to be call the render destroy once the animations complete.

This has been reported internally in:
- http://b/271251353#comment12
- http://b/282004950#comment5

PR Close #50860
2023-06-27 06:27:15 -07:00
Matthieu Riegler
5986ff54ec refactor(platform-browser): remove #9100 todos. (#49406)
This commit assigns the correct type instead of `any`.

PR Close #49406
2023-06-21 11:43:45 -07:00
Alan Agius
4550fe42f7 refactor: use queueMicrotask to schedule micro tasks instead of various helpers (#50485)
`queueMicrotask` is an API which is supported by all browser and Node.js versions.

PR Close #50485
2023-06-15 16:38:21 +02:00
Matthieu Riegler
0c441f6d64 refactor(platform-browser): Remove BrowserDetection (#50411)
Our tests should rely on the running browser.

PR Close #50411
2023-05-30 13:06:28 -07:00
Matthieu Riegler
80fe08be96 refactor(platform-browser): Throw tree-shakable errors. (#49341)
In a effort to have more tree-shakable errors, this commit transforms every `Error` into a tree-shakable `RuntimeError`

PR Close #49341
2023-05-04 12:21:20 +02:00
Alan Agius
2703fd6260 refactor: remove deprecated EventManager method addGlobalEventListener (#49645)
This commit removed the deprecated `EventManager` method  `addGlobalEventListener`.

BREAKING CHANGE: Deprecated `EventManager` method `addGlobalEventListener` has been removed as it is not used by Ivy.

PR Close #49645
2023-03-30 09:47:54 -07:00
Alan Agius
e8e36811d5 fix(platform-browser): set nonce attribute in a platform compatible way (#49624)
Setting the `nonce` attribute using the property is not supported by Domino. This change update the usage to use `setAttribute` and also add a test to verify that the `nonce` is set when it should.

PR Close #49624
2023-03-29 09:26:54 -07:00
Alan Agius
c934a8e72b fix(platform-browser): only add ng-app-id to style on server side (#49465)
This commit fixes an issue where it causes issues in G3 when we add `ng-app-id` on browser apps.

PR Close #49465
2023-03-17 17:26:27 +01:00
Alan Agius
9636910c01 refactor(platform-browser): rename ng-app style attribute to ng-app-id (#49424)
`ng-app` is an AngularJS attribute, see https://docs.angularjs.org/api/ng/directive/ngApp. Using this attribute on a non AngularJS element can cause DI issues in AngularJS when running an AngularJS and Angular application on the same page.

As such, we avoid such problems the Angular `ng-app` attribute is renamed to `ng-app-id`.

PR Close #49424
2023-03-17 10:46:03 +01:00
Alan Agius
9ab9a2a817 refactor(platform-browser): combine DomSharedStylesHost and SharedStylesHost (#49424)
The mentioned 2 classes have been combined since it is no longer required to have a separate `SharedStylesHost` for SSR. This changes also reduces the memory usage footprint as remove 1 Map that stores the CSS strings.

PR Close #49424
2023-03-17 10:46:03 +01:00
Alan Agius
9165ff2517 fix(platform-browser): reuse server generated component styles (#48253)
Prior to this change component styles generated on the server where removed prior to the client side component being rendered and attached it's own styles. In some cases this caused flickering. To mitigate this `initialNavigation: enabledBlocking'` was introduced which allowed the remove of server styles to be defer to a latter stage when the application has finished initialization.

This commit changes the need for this, by not removing the server generated component styles and reuse them for client side rendering.

PR Close #48253
2023-03-09 09:33:34 -08:00
Alan Agius
02d5e8d79d fix(platform-browser): remove styles from DOM of destroyed components (#48298)
Currently style of components using `encapsulation`, `None` or `Emulated` will not be removed from the DOM once the component get destroyed.

This change addresses this by keeping track of the number of times a component is rendered, when the component is destroyed the counter is decreased and once this reaches zero the style element is removed from the DOM.

Currently, this new behaviour is on opt-in bases, but it will be changed in the next major version.

To opt-in, set the `REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY` DI token to `true`.

Example
```ts
@NgModule({
 declarations: [
   AppComponent,
 ],
 imports: [
   BrowserModule
 ],
 providers: [
   { provide: REMOVE_STYLES_ON_COMPONENT_DESTROY, useValue: true }
 ],
 bootstrap: [AppComponent]
})
export class AppModule { }
```

Closes #16670

PR Close #48298
2023-02-16 15:31:24 -08:00
dario-piotrowicz
87fe3161d4 refactor: remove unnecessary test support check utilities (#47543)
remove the following utilities used in unit tests which check for features
that are supported by all supported browsers:
 - supportsCustomElements
 - supportsWebAnimation
 - supportsRegExUnicodeFlag
 - supportsTemplateElement

also remove the following utilities which check for features that are
not supported (and aren't going to be) by any of the supported browsers:
 - supportsDeprecatedCustomCustomElementsV0
 - supportsDeprecatedShadowDomV0

PR Close #47543
2023-01-24 21:06:09 +00:00
Paul Gschwendtner
5c10efe002 build: fix legacy saucelabs test bundle generation after ESM changes (#48521)
ZoneJS is no longer loaded as an UMD, but instead is included as part
of the browser init entry-point. This means that ZoneJS is bundled and
the ESBuild logic needs to be adjusted for that.

PR Close #48521
2022-12-19 19:50:44 +00:00
Paul Gschwendtner
653e122868 refactor: update platform-browser tests to run as ESM (#48521)
`platform-browser` tests now run in ESM and with `.mjs` output, so
the build targets and tests need to be updated.

Here we change the `zone_event_unpatched` script to include the
`.init` suffix that will be picked up by `spec_bundle`.

Also some circular dependency tests are updated to refer to the
`.mjs` files.

PR Close #48521
2022-12-19 19:50:43 +00:00
Jessica Janiuk
a67a8b2fc7 refactor(platform-browser): Updates keyboard event library to support code field (#46030)
On MacOS, pressing the alt key and another key turns into symbols, and
doesn't match the intended behavior. For example, `keydown.alt.s`
reports instead as `keydown.alt.ß`. We rely on the `key` field and not
the `code` field, which properly reports the code for S in this case.

This change adds support to allow users to specify they want to look at
the `code` field instead of the `key` field within their event string.
Example: `keydown.code.alt.leftshift` would only match the LeftShift and
not the right shift based on code values. It would also allow the user
to specify `keydown.code.alt.keys` to match S instead of ß when alt /
option is pressed on MacOS and would also work on Windows.

Fixes #45992

PR Close #46030
2022-07-18 15:28:58 +00:00
Paul Gschwendtner
0934011b03 test: avoid test fixture affecting zone in all web tests (#46511)
We have a file called `test-events.js` (named in an ambiguous way
anyway) that runs for all Karma web tests and configures ZoneJS to
not patch the `scroll` event. There are two issues:

1. The patch applies to all web tests. This could cause unexpected
   issues.
2. The file is named ambiguously and also is placed at the project root,
   in a wrong spot.

Additionally, the test doesn't even fail when the file is removed. This
commit applies the Zone config locally to the closest build target and
also reworks the test to actually ensure it's testing what it describes.

PR Close #46511
2022-06-27 15:46:41 -07:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
41223a81f2 build: update to jasmine 4.0 (#45558)
Updates us to version 4.0 of Jasmine and fixes some errors that were the result of us depending upon deprecated APIs. We need to do this both to stay up to date and because it was going to break eventually, because one of the Bazel packages was logging a deprecation warning that version 4.0 was required.

There were also some cases where the state of `ngDevMode` had started leaking out between tests.

PR Close #45558
2022-04-11 16:25:28 +00:00
Jessica Janiuk
7a37fe9f28 Revert "build: update to jasmine 4.0 (#45558)" (#45566)
This reverts commit a248df0682.

PR Close #45566
2022-04-08 19:07:29 +00:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
a248df0682 build: update to jasmine 4.0 (#45558)
Updates us to version 4.0 of Jasmine and fixes some errors that were the result of us depending upon deprecated APIs. We need to do this both to stay up to date and because it was going to break eventually, because one of the Bazel packages was logging a deprecation warning that version 4.0 was required.

There were also some cases where the state of `ngDevMode` had started leaking out between tests.

PR Close #45558
2022-04-08 15:55:58 +00:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
9fa6f5a552 fix(core): incorrectly inserting elements inside <template> element (#43429)
Currently whenever we insert element we do it directly on the node using `appendChild` or `insertBefore`, however this doesn't work with `<template>` elements where the `template.content` has to be used.

These changes add a few checks to call `appendChild` and `insertBefore` on the `content` of the template.

Fixes #15557.

PR Close #43429
2022-03-08 10:22:18 -08:00
arturovt
a01bcb8e7e fix(platform-browser): do not run change detection when loading Hammer (#44921)
The Hammer.JS might be loaded asynchronously if the `HAMMER_LOADER` token is provided.
Its loading causes additional change detection cycles when the script `load` event is fired
and the `import()` promise resolves. Its loading doesn't have to require Angular running `tick()`
since the Hammer instance is created outside of the Angular zone anyway.

BREAKING CHANGE:

This change may cause a breaking change in unit tests that are implicitly depending on a specific
number and sequence of change detections in order for their assertions to pass.

PR Close #44921
2022-02-02 19:50:46 +00:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
359103274b test: clean up more entryComponents usages (#44561)
Cleans up some more tests that were using `entryComponents`.

PR Close #44561
2022-01-06 18:36:22 +00:00
Paul Gschwendtner
b5ab7aff43 refactor: add override keyword to members implementing abstract declarations (#42512)
In combination with the TS `noImplicitOverride` compatibility changes,
we also want to follow the best-practice of adding `override` to
members which are implemented as part of abstract classes. This
commit fixes all instances which will be flagged as part of the
custom `no-implicit-override-abstract` TSLint rule.

PR Close #42512
2021-07-12 13:11:17 -07:00
Paul Gschwendtner
a2975c7507 refactor(platform-browser): ensure compatibility with noImplicitOverride (#42512)
Adds the `override` keyword to the `platform-browser` sources to ensure
compatibility with `noImplicitOverride`.

PR Close #42512
2021-07-12 13:11:15 -07:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
a787f78074 test: clean up internal testing utilities (#42177)
We have some internal proxies for all of the Jasmine functions, as well as some other helpers. This code hasn't been touched in more than 5 years, it can lead to confusion and it isn't really necessary since the same can be achieved using Jasmine.

These changes remove most of the code and clean up our existing unit tests.

PR Close #42177
2021-05-26 20:07:25 +00:00
JoostK
96624b71a7 fix(platform-browser): prevent memory leak of style nodes if shadow DOM encapsulation is used (#42005)
Prior to this change, any inserted `<style>` nodes into shadow dom trees would be retained
in memory, even after the shadow dom tree has been removed. This commit fixes the memory
leak by tracking the inserted `<style>` nodes per host element, such that removal of the
host element also releases the style nodes.

Fixes #36655

PR Close #42005
2021-05-10 16:12:19 -04:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
3c66b100dd perf(common): remove unused methods from DomAdapter (#41102)
The `DomAdapter` is present in all Angular apps and its methods aren't tree shakeable.
These changes remove the methods that either aren't being used anymore or were only
used by our own tests. Note that these changes aren't breaking, because the adapter
is an internal API.

The following methods were removed:
* `getProperty` - only used within our own tests.
* `log` - Guaranteed to be defined on `console`.
* `logGroup` and `logGroupEnd` - Only used in one place. It was in the DomAdapter for built-in null checking.
* `logGroupEnd` - Only used in one place. It was placed in the DomAdapter for built in null checking.
* `performanceNow` - Only used in one place that has to be invoked through the browser console.
* `supportsCookies` - Unused.
* `getCookie` - Unused.
* `getLocation` and `getHistory` - Only used in one place which appears to have access to the DOM
already, because it had direct accesses to `window`. Furthermore, even if this was being used
in a non-browser context already, the `DominoAdapter` was set up to throw an error.

The following APIs were changed to be more compact:
* `supportsDOMEvents` - Changed to a readonly property.
* `remove` - No longer returns the removed node.

PR Close #41102
2021-03-10 11:48:24 -08:00
JiaLiPassion
dc9fd1aaef fix(core): NgZone coaleascing options should trigger onStable correctly (#40540)
fix https://github.com/angular/components/issues/21674

When setting `ngZoneRunCoalescing` to true, `onStable` is not emitted correctly.
the reason is before this commit, the code looks like this:

```
// application code call `ngZone.run()`
ngzone.run(() => {}); // step 1

// inside NgZone, in the OnInvoke hook, NgZone try to delay the checkStable()

function delayChangeDetectionForEvents(zone: NgZonePrivate) {
  if (zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId !== -1) { // step 9
    return;
  }
  zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId = zone.nativeRequestAnimationFrame.call(global, () => { // step 2
    if (!zone.fakeTopEventTask) {
      zone.fakeTopEventTask = Zone.root.scheduleEventTask('fakeTopEventTask', () => {
        zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId = -1; // step 3
        updateMicroTaskStatus(zone); // step 4
        checkStable(zone); // step 6
      }, undefined, () => {}, () => {});
    }
    zone.fakeTopEventTask.invoke();
  });
  updatemicroTaskStatus(zone);
}

function updateMicroTaskStatus(zone: NgZonePrivate, ignoreCheckRAFId = false) {
  if (zone._hasPendingMicrotasks ||
      ((zone.shouldCoalesceEventChangeDetection || zone.shouldCoalesceRunChangeDetection) &&
       zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId !== -1)) { // step 5
    zone.hasPendingMicrotasks = true;
  } else {
    zone.hasPendingMicrotasks = false;
  }
}

function checkStable(zone: NgZonePrivate) {
  if (zone._nesting == 0 && !zone.hasPendingMicrotasks && !zone.isStable) { // step 7
    try {
      zone._nesting++;
      zone.onMicrotaskEmpty.emit(null);
    ...
}

// application ref subscribe onMicroTaskEmpty
ngzone.onMicroTaskEmpty.subscribe(() => {
  ngzone.run(() => { // step 8
    tick();
  });
});

```

and the process is:
1. step 1: application call ngZone.run()
2. step 2: NgZone delay the checkStable() call in a requestAnimationFrame, and also set
zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId
3. step 3: Inside the requestAnimationFrame callback, reset zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId first
4. step 4: update microTask status
5, step 5: if zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId is -1, that means no microTask pending.
6. step 6: checkStable and trigger onMicrotaskEmpty emitter.
7. step 7: ApplicationRef subscribed onMicrotaskEmpty, so it will call another `ngZone.run()` to process
tick()
8. step 8: And this new `ngZone.run()` will try to check `zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId` in `step 9`
when trying to delay the checkStable(), and since the zone.lastRequestAnimationFrameId is already reset
to -1 in step 3, so this ngZone.run() will run into step 2 again.
9. and become a infinite loop..., so onStable is never emit

in this commit, there is a new flag `zone.isCheckStableRunning` added to
prevent re-entry when `shouldCoaleascing` flag is enabled.

PR Close #40540
2021-02-22 10:01:31 -08:00
arturovt
228b5f73b1 fix(platform-browser): ensure that Hammer loader is called only once (#40911)
Currently, the function that is provided through `HAMMER_LOADER` is called the
same number of times as the `HammerGesturesPlugin.addEventListener` method is called
(until the Hammer is loaded).

This commit adds a class property in which the loader call is saved, thereby
preventing multiple calls to the loader function.

PR Close #25995

PR Close #40911
2021-02-19 09:08:34 -08:00
JiaLiPassion
5e92d649f2 feat(core): add shouldCoalesceRunChangeDetection option to coalesce change detections in the same event loop. (#39422)
Close #39348

Now `NgZone` has an option `shouldCoalesceEventChangeDetection` to coalesce
multiple event handler's change detections to one async change detection.

And there are some cases other than `event handler` have the same issues.
In #39348, the case like this.

```
// This code results in one change detection occurring per
// ngZone.run() call. This is entirely feasible, and can be a serious
// performance issue.
for (let i = 0; i < 100; i++) {
  this.ngZone.run(() => {
    // do something
  });
}
```

So such kind of case will trigger multiple change detections.
And now with Ivy, we have a new `markDirty()` API will schedule
a requestAnimationFrame to trigger change detection and also coalesce
the change detections in the same event loop, `markDirty()` API doesn't
only take care `event handler` but also all other cases `sync/macroTask/..`

So this PR add a new option to coalesce change detections for all cases.

test(core): add test case for shouldCoalesceEventChangeDetection option

Add new test cases for current `shouldCoalesceEventChangeDetection` in `ng_zone.spec`, since
currently we only have integration test for this one.

PR Close #39422
2020-11-16 08:58:50 -08:00
Kristiyan Kostadinov
4a1c12c773 feat(core): remove ViewEncapsulation.Native (#38882)
Removes `ViewEncapsulation.Native` which has been deprecated for several major versions.

BREAKING CHANGES:
* `ViewEncapsulation.Native` has been removed. Use `ViewEncapsulation.ShadowDom` instead. Existing
usages will be updated automatically by `ng update`.

PR Close #38882
2020-10-08 11:56:03 -07:00
Joey Perrott
f979914d4e test(platform-browser): remove usage of blacklist in test naming (#38928)
Remove usage of blacklist in test name.

PR Close #38928
2020-09-23 15:47:28 -04:00
JiaLiPassion
284123c6ba fix(core): should fake a top event task when coalescing events to prevent draining microTaskQueue too early. (#36841)
Close #36839.

This is a known issue of zone.js,

```
(window as any)[(Zone as any).__symbol__('setTimeout')](() => {
  let log = '';
  button.addEventListener('click', () => {
    Zone.current.scheduleMicroTask('test', () => log += 'microtask;');
    log += 'click;';
  });
  button.click();
  expect(log).toEqual('click;microtask;');
  done();
});
```

Since in this case, we use native `setTimeout` which is not a ZoneTask,
so zone.js consider the button click handler as the top Task then drain the
microTaskQueue after the click at once, which is not correct(too early).

This case was an edge case and not reported by the users, until we have the
new option ngZoneEventCoalescing, since the event coalescing will happen
in native requestAnimationFrame, so it will not be a ZoneTask, and zone.js will
consider any Task happen in the change detection stage as the top task, and if
there are any microTasks(such as Promise.then) happen in the process, it may be
drained earlier than it should be, so to prevent this situation, we need to schedule
a fake event task and run the change detection check in this fake event task,
so the Task happen in the change detection stage will not be
considered as top ZoneTask.

PR Close #36841
2020-06-11 18:54:22 -07:00
Joey Perrott
d1ea1f4c7f build: update license headers to reference Google LLC (#37205)
Update the license headers throughout the repository to reference Google LLC
rather than Google Inc, for the required license headers.

PR Close #37205
2020-05-26 14:26:58 -04:00
Joey Perrott
698b0288be build: reformat repo to new clang@1.4.0 (#36613)
PR Close #36613
2020-04-14 12:08:36 -07:00
JiaLiPassion
41667de778 fix(zone.js): add issue numbers of @types/jasmine to the test cases (#34625)
Some cases will still need to use `spy as any` cast, because `@types/jasmine` have some issues,
1. The issue jasmine doesn't handle optional method properties, https://github.com/DefinitelyTyped/DefinitelyTyped/issues/43486
2. The issue jasmine doesn't handle overload method correctly, https://github.com/DefinitelyTyped/DefinitelyTyped/issues/42455

PR Close #34625
2020-04-08 12:10:34 -07:00
JiaLiPassion
ef4736d052 build: update jasmine to 3.5 (#34625)
1. update jasmine to 3.5
2. update @types/jasmine to 3.5
3. update @types/jasminewd2 to 2.0.8

Also fix several cases, the new jasmine 3 will help to create test cases correctly,
such as in the `jasmine 2.x` version, the following case will pass

```
expect(1 == 2);
```

But in jsamine 3, the case will need to be

```
expect(1 == 2).toBeTrue();
```

PR Close #34625
2020-04-08 12:10:34 -07:00
JiaLiPassion
d8be830fce fix: resolve event listeners not correct when registered outside of ngZone (#33711)
Close #33687.

PR Close #33711
2019-11-11 14:00:31 -08:00
JiaLiPassion
44623a1161 feat: add a flag in bootstrap to enable coalesce event change detection to improve performance (#30533)
PR Close #30533
2019-11-05 18:58:25 +00:00
Matias Niemelä
082aed6e46 revert: feat: add a flag in bootstrap to enable coalesce event change detection to improve performance (#30533) (#33230)
This reverts commit 21c1e14385.

PR Close #33230
2019-10-17 12:50:04 -04:00
JiaLiPassion
21c1e14385 feat: add a flag in bootstrap to enable coalesce event change detection to improve performance (#30533)
PR Close #30533
2019-10-16 14:38:36 -04:00
Kara Erickson
89434e09c2 refactor(core): move Meta methods that only have one version from DomAdapter (#32408)
PR Close #32408
2019-09-03 11:59:39 -07:00
Misko Hevery
8a47b48912 refactor: Move dom_adapter.ts to @angular/common (#32154)
This work is needed in preparation for turning tokens into tree-shakable injectables.

PR Close #32154
2019-08-29 21:51:56 -07:00
Kara Erickson
f3e4cb491e refactor(core): remove testing-only event utilities from DomAdapters (#32291)
PR Close #32291
2019-08-28 17:10:30 -07:00